“We’re not meant for happiness, you and I.”
Rebecca is one of those books that appears on every “Books You Must Read Before You Die” type lists. Considered by many to be one of the greatest novels of all time I felt obligated to pick this title up at some point.
I love a good brooding British novel as much as the next white, nerdy, bookish girl but Rebecca didn’t necessarily resonate as much as something like Tess of the D’Urbervilles or Jane Eyre. the mystery was interesting enough to keep me engaged but I found myself being pulled from the story quite often to point out certain plot shortcomings or really awkward phrasing, even for the time period.
While researching the life of the author, one of my favorite pastimes when reading classic novels, I learned that the author had been accused of plagiarizing Rebecca from a “1934 book, A Sucessora (The Successor), by Brazilian writer Carolina Nabuco” (Wikipedia, https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daphne_du_Maurier). I am curious about the accusation and have added the book to my TBR list to compare. I wouldn’t be at all surprised if the author had borrowed significant portions of the book, I didn’t feel reading it that she had mastered the plot. It felt like a borrowed horse she could barely control.
Rebecca is a widely influential novel. It’s inspired Alfred Hitchcock, Stephen King, Ken Follett, and many others. I’m going to chalk this up to the fact that there were so few authorial voices at the time, most diverse authors were not given the same platform as people like Daphne du Maurier though they had immensely more talent. It also didn’t hurt that she had many connections to the publishing industry.
I’ve devoted a lot of this review to the negatives, but I did somewhat enjoy this book. It by no means changed my life or shifted my worldview and frankly I felt like Rebecca came out feeling like a kind of anti-hero who controlled her own destiny at a time when women still very much depended on men. I am not sure the author particularly meant to make that impression.
The book takes a few interesting turns at opportune moments when I might have been tempted to set it aside and is worth finishing for the resolution, it wasn’t what I expected which I appreciated.
Is this on my list of books you MUST read before you die?
But I’d put it on a “Books You Might Want to Read if the Book You Really Want to Read Has a Long Hold List at the Public Library” list.